
Commentary · December 2026
Routs, Rifts & Reckonings
This month in Commentary, from the GOP’s election-night collapse to a pincer closing on American Jews
Two weeks after Election Day, the December issue of Commentary leads with a post-mortem of what its editor and senior writer call the repudiation of Donald Trump’s Republican Party. The rest of the issue widens the lens: a warning that American Jews are now squeezed from left and right, a report from a national-conservative conference gone sour, a combat expert’s takedown of a prize-winning Gaza documentary, Joseph Epstein on football, and a stack of reviews running from Simon Sebag Montefiore’s Middle East to Rod Serling’s Twilight Zone.
Here is what is inside, with our notes on the arguments each writer makes.
The Cover
The Repudiation of Donald Trump’s GOP
The cover story · By Noah Rothman and John Podhoretz
The Democrats’ collapse after 2016, the authors argue, took eight years of Barack Obama to build. The Republicans’ came in a single night. On November 3, Democrats gained at least 43 House seats and eight Senate seats, raised their governorships from 24 to 30, and went from controlling 39 state legislative chambers to 51. States under one-party Democratic control now outnumber Republican ones, 22 to 17. The South delivered the sharpest shocks: Jon Ossoff won Georgia by 18 points, Keisha Lance Bottoms took the governor’s mansion, Roy Cooper won Thom Tillis’s old North Carolina seat, and in Texas, Greg Abbott lost along with almost every Republican statewide official, leaving Ted Cruz as the last one standing. Trump had asked voters to treat the midterms as a vote on him, the authors note, and they did. Their conclusion: this was not an anti-incumbent wave but an anti-Republican one, and the party is unlikely to win back the Senate in 2028, perhaps not even in 2030.
The Editorial
The Pincer Attack Against American Jews
A Commentary editorial · By the Editors
The editors start from the “horseshoe theory,” the idea that the far left and far right bend toward each other until they nearly meet. Their argument is that hatred of Jews is where the two ends now touch, leaving American Jews caught between a progressive left hostile to Israel and a populist right flirting with old conspiracies.
Essays
The Horrors of NatCon
Essay · By Naya Lekht
This year’s National Conservatism conference, the movement Yoram Hazony launched in Washington in 2019, met in Jerusalem. Lekht, a scholar of antisemitism, argues that it betrayed conservatism. A gathering meant to court pro-Trump Jews instead showcased a young right weary of Israel, and the fiercest arguments centred on a speech by Jonathan Keeperman that, in her account, flattered the young rather than challenging them.
The Dawn of Western Palestinianism
Essay · By Simone Rodan-Benzaquen
Rodan-Benzaquen traces how the Palestinian flag has become a banner for almost every progressive cause in the West, from climate to race to anti-capitalism. Her argument is that in standing for everything, it has stopped standing for the Palestinians themselves.
The Evil of NAZA
Essay · By John Spencer
“NAZA,” by the Israeli journalists Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, premiered by surprise at the Venice Film Festival in September and won a special jury prize. Built on anonymous testimony from Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers, it alleges that civilian deaths were deliberately built into Israel’s targeting in Gaza. Spencer, who chairs urban-warfare studies at West Point’s Modern War Institute, calls the film sensationalist and takes its central claims apart, including the way it attributes Gaza’s entire death toll to Israel.
Necessary Roughness?
Essay · By Joseph Epstein
The veteran essayist takes the measure of the football business, America’s most popular sport and, he suggests, its most questionable.
On a Clear Day, You Can See a Sociopath
Film · By Nancy Rommelmann
Rommelmann praises “You Can See Everything,” Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s nearly three-hour A24 documentary, shot in secret, that follows the Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes through her last 34 days before prison. Its achievement, in her reading, is to let a master performer reveal herself.
The Columns
The Monstering of Haley Stevens
Washington Commentary · By James Kirchick
Representative Haley Stevens lost Michigan’s Democratic Senate primary to Abdul El-Sayed, then, on the eve of the election, withdrew her endorsement and backed the Republican, Mike Rogers, citing El-Sayed’s hostility to Israel. Kirchick defends her against the torrent of abuse from her own party, which branded her a traitor.
There’s No Accounting for Accountability
Social Commentary · By Christine Rosen
Rosen asks why almost no one seems to answer for failure anymore, from pandemic-era fraud to the age of artificial intelligence.
The Beauty of Being Askew
Jewish Commentary · By Meir Y. Soloveichik
Rabbi Soloveichik turns to the Touro Synagogue in Newport, Rhode Island, America’s oldest surviving synagogue, which sits at an angle on its lot so that its ark faces east toward Jerusalem. He finds in that tilt a lesson about Jewish life in America.
Liquidity Events
Hollywood Commentary · By Rob Long
The screenwriter and producer on how money moves through show business now that new media have upended the old model.
Books
Fire Burn and Cauldron Bubble
Reviewed by Jonathan Schanzer
The Cauldron is Simon Sebag Montefiore’s history of the modern Middle East from 1900 to the present, from the founding of Saudi Arabia to the Iranian revolution and the failed Arab Spring.
Taking No Prisoners
Reviewed by Michael M. Rosen
In Brink, Brett McGurk, who served four presidents and led America’s hostage talks after October 7, gives the first insider account of the negotiations to free the captives Hamas took into Gaza.
Wallowing in the Meyer
Reviewed by Tal Fortgang
Stephanie Slade’s Fusionism urges conservatives to revive Frank Meyer’s marriage of liberty and virtue, the idea that held the Reagan-era right together. Fortgang weighs whether that old synthesis can still hold.
Islam’s Liberal Alibi
Reviewed by Brian Stewart
Rozina Ali’s Seasons of Fury follows four families to chart the rise of Islamophobia in America since 9/11. Stewart takes a skeptical look at its argument.
School of Hard Knocks
Reviewed by Clare McHugh
American Hagwon, Min Jin Lee’s first novel since Pachinko, follows a Korean American family through the pressure-cooker world of after-school cram academies.
Requiem for a Heavyweight
Reviewed by Rick Marin
Alan Sepinwall’s Serling is a new life of the creator of The Twilight Zone. The review borrows its title from Serling’s celebrated 1956 television play about a fighter at the end of the line.
Before You Close the Issue
Was November 3 a verdict on one man, or the first draw of a new political map?
Drawn from Commentary, December 2026, where the full articles are available to subscribers.
— The Editors, Intellicurious —






